Sunday, April 16, 2017

College 101 - What I Learned and What I Wish Someone Had Told Me

So this past week Cole declined admission to Carolina and East Carolina.  And I may or may not have sat across from him sobbing.  Yes, sobbing.  I am not exactly sure why but my son seems to have part of the answer.  As I was sniffling and drying my eyes, lamenting that I would have to redo my eye makeup, I commented, "This is so dumb.  I don't know why I'm crying."  He looked up from his laptop and said, "It's because I'm taking your security blanket away, I'm taking away your back up plan."  I think he is right.  We have no back up plan now.  We are all in at Liberty and I can tell you it is a scary.  It is a faith filled place but it is also far from the shore, out in the middle of the lake!


So we talked about that for a little while, about how this whole thing is a giant leap of faith and I reminded him that if for some reason he loses the scholarship, he likely will not be able to stay at Liberty.  He says he understands.  I think he does, I hope and pray he does.

We talked, he typed, I cried.  I could not stop.  As he continued to point and click, I could feel my eyelids getting puffy and swollen.  In a shameless attempt, I finally I said, "It's just that my Dad always wanted me to go to Carolina and I didn't have the guts to apply.  I was scared I would not be admitted." Undeterred, he looked up from his laptop and said, "You made up for it.  I applied.  I got in."  I suppose he is right but it is crazy the emotion that can be attached to a decision I made over 20 years ago.  I was reminded that sometimes you just need to go for it and see what happens.  Seems like that is lesson God has been teaching and reteaching me lately.  I'm glad my son is learning this lesson early in his life.

Several times over the past year, friends have asked me to write what I learned and what I would do differently during the college search process.  This is my feeble to attempt to put those thoughts into words.  Yes, I have learned a lot of head knowledge but as I mentioned in my last blog I have learned much more in heart knowledge.  In an attempt to seek higher education options for my child, God was seeking deeper heart knowledge for me.

What I Learned and What I Would Do Differently:

1.  In the spring of the sophomore year have your child take both the SAT and the ACT.  Once the scores are back, focus on the test with the better score.  For us, that was the ACT.  We had a teacher tutor Cole on taking the test.  They met once a week for several weeks and he also worked through an ACT workbook. He took the test again the spring of his junior year. He was able to increase his score by 2 points which translated into more money for institutional merit scholarships.   Our goal was to have all testing done by the end of the junior year so he could halfway enjoy his senior year (minus completing the college applications and scholarship essays).  I am so glad we did this and I will work towards this goal with the other kids.  The tests are just part of the process, not all of it, but getting it done early frees up your mind and schedule to focus on other things.

2.  I would visit a variety of places.  Have your student make a list of colleges he thinks might suit him.  This was very difficult for us.  I am the one who did most of the researching.  Until very recently, Cole just couldn't get his head around going to college.  It's like he didn't quite understand that going to CCS next year is not an option.  I have talked to other parents whose child was the same way.  I think the whole process is overwhelming.  So I really helped Cole with this.  I researched some colleges and offered some ideas to him. I had no idea what I was doing either.  Several of our visits were based on advice from friends. I had no experience with this.  I applied to one school, ECU.  I didn't have the courage to apply to Carolina and I thought about applying to Meredith or Peace College in Raleigh.  My best friend said she was going to ECU and asked me to go with her.  I said yes and it was done.  A lot has changed in the world of college admissions over the past twenty years.  Once Cole had a more narrow list, we could start making some visits.  Ask yourself if you want a big or small atmosphere, near or far from home, religious or secular, private or public.  If you know your course of study or intended major, research those schools.  We visited lots of places in all these categories.  Looking back now, there are a few that I think were probably a waste of time but we didn't know that until after we visited. I was told that you will get a "feel for a place" once you step on campus and I found that to be true. There were 3 schools in particular that I knew were not for us within moments of arriving on campus.  Some of our visits were a waste of time.  In retrospect (and with future children) I will not make so many visits.  I'm almost of the mind to pick 3 based on the literature and visit those three.  Thankfully Caleb's interests are much more narrow so that automatically eliminated several places.


3.  I would make 2 visits to colleges that you are serious about.  So you have your list, go visit the spring of the junior year.  Go for either a 1:1 visit or a "Welcome Days" visit.   These are totally different kinds of visits.  I wish someone had told me this.  Most of our visits were 1:1 visits.  Go to a "Welcome Day" in the spring and if you have a good experience go back for a 1:1 early in the fall.  The Welcome Days are designed to do just that, make you feel welcome.  You aren't eating alone in the lunchroom.  You aren't the only visitor observing a class.  You get a vibe for the campus.  I think part of why Cole didn't like a few places on our list was because we were the only visitors.  It felt awkward.  Go back in the fall and make a department visit and talk to the professors.  I seriously wish we had done our visits this way.  These are two questions to ask given to me by my friend, Lane Rice:

What is the average class size for a freshman class and the average class size in the intended major?  If you don't know the intended major, ask about class size in the upper school.

What do your students do after graduation?  What graduate schools are your students going to?  Who is hiring your graduates?

4.  Write the essays for the Common App the summer before the senior year.  Someone gave us this advice and we did not follow it.  When school started we quickly found out why we were offered this advice.  Cole was slammed in between his regular schoolwork, a class at the community college, working a part time job, and playing soccer.  Then he had to write all these essays.  He was stressed out and I was too.  I had my kitchen cabinet full of sticky notes with deadlines and things to do.  The sticky notes served as our external memory.  I still did not learn this lesson with Caleb.  He wrote his essays for the Common App this fall and once again it was a lot of work.  It is doable but I would advise at least getting a draft ready in the summer.  Or you can do what we did and truly enjoy summer and worry about the essays later.  There will be time to write them.

5.  I am on the fence about AP classes.  I really could take it or leave it but our education goals are probably different than yours.  I realize that colleges want to know that your child took the most rigorous courses offered.  I get that.  Cole's experience really has been a good one because his classes meet for an entire year not a semester.  If they were semester classes, I would think twice.  You really need to evaluate what your goals are.  Are you trying to get as much college credit before you get to college?  Are you trying to save money?  When you think about these things, try to think about how much growing and maturing happens between 18 and 22.  Do you want your student to graduate from college at 20?  Is that your goal?  Also remember that just taking the AP class does not guarantee credit.  You still have to pay to test and then score a certain score (which varies by college) to obtain credit.  If your goal is college credit and or to save money, a more certain way to get that would be to take classes through the community college starting in 11th grade.  These are guaranteed to transfer and you don't have to pay for a test.  Caleb is taking 2 AP classes this year and he took 1 his junior year.  He is taking one class per semester at the community college.  So far this has been a fairly good pace and not too overwhelming.  Again my goal in taking these dual enrollment classes is exposure but I am not anxious for him to graduate college at 20 years old.  If he has 12 or so hours going into college, I think that is sufficient.

6.  Are you concerned about the spiritual condition on campus?  For us, because we are Christians, this was important.  Now before you say, blah, blah, that is why he is going to Liberty, you would be wrong.  Did you read the first paragraph?  There were two public schools high on our list.  I absolutely think that Christian students can thrive at a public school but it is going to require some work.  They will have to find their people and I would think that will involve a little struggle.  These are more questions from my friend, Lane.  I am sharing these because I think they are invaluable. These questions helped us rule out some colleges that advertise themselves as Christian.

Check out the campus ministries.  Always, always, always.  Who are their campus ministers?  When you get home, look them up, where they went to seminary can tell you a lot about what they believe.  If the campus has RUF (Reformed University Fellowship), that is going to consistently be a pretty conservative campus ministry.  They have some theological differences from FWB or Southern Baptists, mostly in the area of election/Calvinism, but their process for training and placing their ministers is unparalleled.  

 I still think this is solid advice.  It is something we are thinking about as we prepare to launch Caleb.

7.  Use the net price calculator on the school's website. This will give you a ballpark figure.  My friend, Kay, suggested that we make an Excel spreadsheet and plug in all the numbers.  Darren did this and it has been invaluable.  He has all the costs, broken down by fees, books, tuition, room/board, etc.  He also has the credits from merit scholarships or grants.  We have been able to compare each school side by side.  Again, this was one of the best pieces of advice we were given and it has been so very helpful!  Yes to this advice a hundred times!  It is invaluable in the planning stage.

8.  College is expensive. It is more expensive than it looks on paper.  You may think your little Suzy is at the top of her class and she will get a full ride somewhere.  Well, I hate to burst your bubble but that probably is not going to happen.  Or you may think that your ballplayer is the best around and he will get a sports scholarship.  I would not bank on it.  I think it's fine to hope for it but I just wouldn't count on it. Cole's test scores are outstanding, his ACT scores are in the top 96% for the nation, the top 98% for North Carolina.  I am not saying that to brag. I am telling you because he has not gotten significant scholarships on top of institutional merit scholarships from the schools to which he applied.  It's a big world out there and there is always someone out there who is smarter or plays ball better than your child.  You need to know that going in.  Yes, the counselors will tell you that there are scholarships for everything.  Practically every place visited said that you can "get a scholarship for anything, even being a left handed Scotsman."  Whatever.  Getting those scholarships takes a lot of work and a lot of writing.  Cole has applied for many.  Many.  Remember, most of those also require essays and many are due at the same time as applications.  You will have to pace yourself.  I wrote all the deadlines on my calendar and shared them with Cole.  It was his job to get the applications filled out and essays written. I proofed them.  Many also require teacher recommendations.  You have to give the teacher time to get these done.  I was very overwhelmed when looking for outside scholarships so I had to narrow our focus.  We decided to apply for scholarships that are for children of veterans.  This narrowed our search and it also narrowed the number of students Cole has to compete against.  Also most of these scholarships winners are not notified until June/July.  You have to make a college decision by May 1.  So you have to make a decision before you know if you will be awarded any outside scholarships.  This is where that spreadsheet is so helpful.  You can play around with the numbers.  If this then this, if not this, then this, etc.  So far, Cole has been awarded two very small awards for local essay contests.  It can be discouraging but I told him he has to look at this process like a job.

Also my cousin, Ann, told me if we were not satisfied with the offer from a school, to go to the department and try to negotiate/show interest.  We took this advice and that is why Cole made the visit to the Honors Program at Liberty.  I don't think he would have been offered a slot if he had not made this visit.  They want to know you are serious and that you want to be in their program. Your pursuit can translate into dollars.

 If your child is interested in ROTC, I would have them apply for the first wave which is in the fall.  The four year scholarships are difficult to get, a three year scholarship is much more realistic.  We were told this by every ROTC program that we visited (Cedarville, ECU, Campbell, Charleston Southern, and Liberty).  According to the professor for military science at Liberty, in the current freshman class, only 25% of cadets are on scholarship. It varies year by year.  This is why you apply for the first wave.  If you don't make the first wave, you still are in the running for second and third waves. So just because you were passed over the first time, doesn't mean you will be passed over permanently.  We are so grateful Cole was awarded a four year scholarship but it's not secure until he passes a medical test and another physical fitness test. The Army will not start paying Liberty until those things are done which hopefully will happen in September.  Until then, Darren and I are paying.  Did I mention college is crazy expensive? Cole would not be going to Liberty unless he had this ROTC scholarship.  Even with institutional merit scholarships, an Honors program scholarship, and other school awards (for early deposit etc.), it still leaves a lot on the table for us.  So we are praying that he passes the medical test and the pt test as soon as possible so Uncle Sam can pick up the tab.

I don't write all this to discourage you.  Really.  I just think that people need to know that yes there is money out there but it is not just given to you.  Number one, you have to find it then number two you have to work for it.  Even ECU was going to be expensive and he was awarded an Honors College scholarship there as well as an ACCESS scholarship.  If ECU is on your list, you should know that scholarships for the Honors program are no longer full tuition.  Cole was awarded half tuition while he has a good friend who was awarded the full tuition offer.  They are currently in the process of doubling the number of students that they will accept and they are paying for that by decreasing scholarships.  Remember, there is always someone out there who is smarter and works harder than your kid.  They may be all that in their little world but that little world turns into the big world when you are talking money and scholarships.  We are hoping and praying that Cole is awarded at least one of these outside scholarships. (He did earn a significant amount in outside/private scholarships but these were not awarded until the summer before his freshman year).  We are hopeful but realistic. 

The Army ROTC scholarship is what made Liberty a reality for Cole.  A combination of the Army scholarship plus academic scholarships that he earned made this possible. As for Caleb, he only has two schools on his list and has no interest in the military.  That is fine with us but it means that after the letters and hopefully, prayerfully some awards come in, we will have to make some tough decisions about where he will attend.  My personal goal for undergraduate education is to get the best while paying the least amount possible. 

9. Complete the FAFSA as soon as it opens in October.  The earlier you apply the more likely you are to receive funds.  A lot of the money is time sensitive so it is to your advantage to apply early.  This is another time where you can be hopeful but you need to be realistic as well.  Our family did not receive federal funds (other than offers for loans) but did receive work study offers from all the universities.  We were offered a small institutional grant at Carolina but they have an additional application in addition to the federal application.  The FAFSA is not as complicated and time consuming as it used to be.  There is a way to link it to your tax information so all of that automatically links up.  My husband completed all the paperwork in less than an hour.

10.  If your child is awarded work study that is wonderful.  However, that money is not taken off your bill.  So yes, you can plug into your spreadsheet that your child will get a $2700 work study credit but he hasn't worked those hours yet so you don't get the money.  You still owe the money and then your student is issued a check as they work.  It is my assumption that you would make your student apply that money toward the next semester.  That is what I would do if Cole were doing work study.  If for some reason his Army scholarship falls through, he will be participating in that program.  His Army scholarship includes a monthly stipend so we are considering that his "work study."  At some colleges, your student is guaranteed a job if they qualify, at others it is a competitive process and they will have to apply/interview.  In my personal opinion, this is one reason your teenager should have a part time job.  This way they have some kind of experience when applying for work study employment.  Also the work study awards varied by school.  Cole was offered work study anywhere from $1200 to $4000.  When we first started getting financial aid award letters from colleges, I was pumped that he qualified for work study.  It wasn't until I read the fine print that I realized you do not get that credit up front.

11.  Once you get your schools narrowed down or once you make a final decision, hopefully earlier than we did, send the AP scores and community college transcripts to the school.  No one told me to do this so Cole had to take placement exams even though he had placed out of classes due to AP/CC credits.  He had to register for Fall classes last week.  He didn't want to take the placement exams but Liberty didn't have his other scores.  I ordered the scores and had to pay a rush fee.  He still wound up having to take the exams because once they get the score reports everything has to be verified which takes time.  Cole wasn't happy about taking the placement tests for things he knew he already had credit for but it was a hoop he had to jump through.  I don't know if other schools have their freshman register in the spring before they start in fall or if it's just Liberty.  I think I registered at summer orientation which makes more sense to me.  Either way, once you make a decision, I would go ahead and send the scores.  You are going to have to do it eventually anyway.  It's $15 for a score report, $25 for a rush report.  You also get a free send when you take the AP exam but if you aren't sure where you are going to college, that really doesn't help you.

12.  Finally, I would add that nothing is written in stone.  Despite doing your research, you may wind up at a place that just isn't a good fit for you.  That is not the end of the world, people transfer all the time.  This is one of those times that definitely calls for honesty and flexibility!

These are just some of the things I have learned that I can think to write about.  If you have other questions, ask me and if I know the answer I will tell you.  I have found this process to be somewhat isolating.  Some parents don't want to share what they know.  I guess it's because they are scared your child might get something they were hoping their child would receive.  My personal thoughts are that God has enough for everyone and His plan for your child is not the same as His plan for my child.  We are all in this boat together so there is no need to be selfish over what you know.  I don't view it as a competition.  I think I am in the minority on that.  So if you have a question, ask me and maybe you won't have to learn some of these lessons the hard way like we did.

2 comments:

shellrae said...

Thank you for your honesty, transparency, and such valuable information for those of us a step or two behind you!! Your last paragraph made me sad, as I wish everyone could have a viewpoint like you said at the end. Why should we be selfish not to share? I think if we took that same view and applied it to sharing the gospel,we would change lives. We need to see our wealth of knowledge not as something to hold onto and keep only to ourselves, but to share it with everyone! Thank you for the reminder. I have been so incredibly blessed by beautiful people like you who are willing to share, I am always so grateful. So again, thank you. 😊

Anonymous said...

Thank you so much, Julie. I affirm your pragmatic q advice, and I learned a few new things as I read. For Noelle, it has been my prayer that she sees God's hand on her life in the process. However, she may not see the big picture for a few years down the road. I love that Cole got the ROTC scholarship, and I LOVE that he will be at LU. My years there were beautiful: I am claiming Hannah and Cole as my own children following in my footsteps.