Tuesday, February 17, 2015

School Mistakes

It's that time of year again.  Many parents are wondering where to send their children to school this fall.  I've been that Mom before ~ the one with all the questions, doubts, insecurities and ideas ~ in many ways I still am that Mom.  Several women, mostly Moms of younger children, have asked me how we made our school decisions.  Today I am writing that story ~ maybe some of you will learn from my mistakes and from the few things that I feel like we have done well.

Honestly, when Cole turned 5  I didn't put a tremendous amount of thought into where he would attend kindergarten.  That may seem shocking but I made my decision based on what other families at my church were doing.  I figured that if it was good for them then it would be good for us.  Mistake #1.  I have since learned that schooling is a very personal and individual choice.  What is right for one child would not be right for another one.  Following my friends, we enrolled Cole in a local private Christian school.  This was one year after my Mom died, Claire was one, Caleb was three, Darren was still deployed and my Dad turned my entire life upside down.  When I look at it from that perspective, I can see why I just did the next thing without asking a lot of questions.  I could barely decide what to wear (because none of my clothes fit since I ate entirely too much fast food while Darren was gone) much less make schooling decisions.  I just did the next thing.  Sometimes when life is hard, all you can do is the next thing.

Cole did well that year.  He is an extremely compliant child and did exactly what he was asked to do.  We had no major issues so I enrolled him at the same school for first grade.  The next year it was Caleb's turn to go to kindergarten.  Again, I was just blindly following along, doing what I had done for Cole. Cole was in second grade, Caleb half day kindergarten.  Mid autumn when Caleb's teacher called to tell me that he had gotten up from his seat in the middle of Math class to erase the board "because she was taking too long to get to the answer" I should have gotten a clue.  I didn't.  She had a lot of patience with Caleb and sadly I did not.  His constant "discipline" issues frustrated me.  Every day I was on pins and needles wondering whether he had gotten in trouble at school that day.  Mistake #2.  Obedience is only part of education, not all of it.  Life is not all about the rules.  While Caleb was bored to tears in kindergarten, Cole was breezing through second grade.  Neither child was being challenged but I had my hands full (overflowing) with my Dad and I didn't try to change anything.  So that year, we enrolled Cole in third grade and Caleb in first.

Only a few days into the school year, I knew that we had made a big mistake.  Caleb and his teacher didn't get along and that is being polite.  She was "old school" and Caleb was "my own way" school.  If I was on pins and needles in kindergarten with his sweet, gentle teacher by the middle of first grade I was on my way to a nervous breakdown with his new teacher.  In fact, I even pulled him out for a few days and enrolled him at the local public school.  Then I was stressed out because the boys were in two different places and I just couldn't do it.  I regret pulling him out and putting back in the same class with the same teacher.  Leaving him in that classroom with that teacher is one of our biggest parenting regrets.  It was a big, huge mistake #3!  All these years later, I don't know if he has fully recovered the self confidence that was shattered that year.  Darren and I both cry when we think of all we put him through, trying to make a square peg fit in a circular hole.

By February of  2008, we knew we had to make a change.  That was very difficult for me.  My Dad had just been diagnosed with cancer and Claire would be starting kindergarten.  I felt nauseous all the time.  I really didn't know what to do or how we were going to pay for it.  It was then that we were introduced to Christ Covenant School.  I liked the idea of classical education although I honestly didn't really know what it was all about.  I just knew that it was different than what we were doing and we needed a change. We decided to cut our losses with the other school.  While Cole could have stayed and probably done quite well, we knew it was not the right place for Caleb.  Remember, lesson #1?  What is right for one child, is not necessarily right for all of them.  Since Cole has such an easy going personality, we decided to move both boys.   At the time, making a decision was hard.  Cole had friends and I didn't want to create more stress in his young life.  That summer was the hardest of our lives. It was harder than even when Darren was deployed.  My Dad was actively dying that entire summer.  I was his primary caretaker and it was all I could do to take care of him and my children.  By this time, Cade had joined our family and was two years old.  I felt like I couldn't make one more decision, one more choice. Once again, I just did the next thing.  We enrolled both boys at CCS for second and fourth grade and Claire in kindergarten.

My Dad died August 15 and school started about ten days later.  I was a mess, emotionally and physically.  I felt like I had been through the fire and I guess in some ways I had.  The one bright spot was that the kids actually liked going to school!  Cole was making friends.  In fact, those same kids are his best friends today.  Caleb was making friends too but we were only a few weeks into school when his teacher called.  I felt that same sick feeling, that feeling of deja vu.  His teacher shared her observations and I knew it was time to make some life changes for Caleb.  I could write another post about the changes we made.  Maybe I will someday but not yet.

So we hummed along through fourth, second, and kindergarten.  In fact, we moved along until Claire was in third grade, Caleb fifth and Cole in the seventh.  I had taken a part time job at a local preschool to help fund this classical education.  By this point, I had learned much more about the classical education model and I knew it was what I wanted for my kids.  So we were doing well until we realized that it was time for Cade to start kindergarten.  That posed a problem because we could barely send three kids to CCS much less four.  I was either going to have to get a full time job or we were going to make some hard decisions.

The idea of homeschooling started coming up more and more often.  It wasn't the first time we had thought about homeschooling.  We aren't wealthy and sending the kids to private school was (is) a big "sacrifice" for us.  It means we do without some things.  Honestly, if I was not committed to classical education, our boys would not be in private school today.  I believe in it so much that we make the adjustments. It's hard especially when I look around and see what other people are doing.  Sometimes we are weary of "adjustments" and that is why the idea of homeschooling first came up.   Some may disagree but I would say that is mistake #4.  A school decision should not be merely a financial decision.  We have seen God provide in amazing ways!  If you never take a leap of faith, you miss the opportunity to see Him work.

This was also the fall that my friend's daughter, Lydia, left for Heaven.  Stacey started homeschooling because of Lydia's illness but even when Lydia was "well" they continued homeschooling.  Her days were full of a simplicity that I longed for.  I realized that the days are long but the years are short.  I was jealous of the time that teachers, women and men that I adore, were spending with my kids.  Lydia's death changed me.  

So we were at the point of making hard decisions.  My friend, Sarah, had been "counseling" me for two years about homeschooling.  As I mentioned, it was not a new idea to us.  I just didn't have any confidence in myself.  That would be mistake #5.  It's not about me.  It's not about what I can or cannot do, it's about what He can do through me.  I analyzed the idea, I cried over it, I made myself sick over it.  I just felt like I couldn't possibly do as well as the school was doing. I remember one noonday sitting in my car, crying on the phone with Sarah.  I still remember what she said.  "You give the school too much credit.  You are one who taught them their letters, you taught them how to count, you taught them how to read, you are the one who takes them to the library every Saturday, you are the one who reads aloud to them, it's you.  You did all that!  Stop selling yourself short!  You can do it, with God, you can do it!"  Stacey showed me the beauty and benefit of homeschooling.  Sarah showed me the purpose and calling of homeschooling. It was no longer a financial decision, it was a calling.  It was a heart decision.

I was sure homeschooling was right for our family.  Then I wasn't so sure.  Remember how what is right for one child, isn't always right for the next one?  Cade didn't really know any different.  He had only been to Memorial for kindergarten and I worked there while he was in class.  For him, homeschooling was just the next thing.  For other children, we had to make some hard choices.  Cole was entering eighth grade.  I knew for sure that I wanted him to have a classical education. (If you are wondering what that means, let me know, I would love to share with you).  The problem was that our local community (Classical Conversations) did not have a program in Greenville for eighth graders.  So I would either have to flesh out his education on my own or he could stay in school.  Once again, being the compliant child, he said he would be fine with whatever decision we made.  We decided to leave Cole at CCS.  Caleb, entering sixth grade, could have gone either way.  Classical Conversations offered a program for his age but Caleb made it very clear that he wanted to stay at school.  Darren made it clear that he felt it was best for Caleb to stay in school.  He wanted Caleb to have the accountability and interaction of being in a classroom.  I wasn't sure but ultimately decided to leave Caleb at CCS.  Claire was open to the idea of coming home.  She was willing to give it a go.  She would be going into fourth grade.

I would be dishonest if I said that it was easy peasy from that point on.  It can be challenging but it has been worth it.  The time I have with Cade and Claire is time I can't get back. I treasure the afternoons we read books together or work on a math problem until we get it right.  I love doing simple art projects, writing stories and learning something new.  I feel like CC has redeemed my own education.  We have learned a timeline from Creation all the way through September 11!  How amazing is that?  I've learned more History and Science than I ever thought I could. It is an amazing program and I love being part of it.

The downside is that when my boys leave for school, I long for them to be home.  That hasn't changed even though I know they are where they need to be.  That is part of the learning of mistake #1.  What is right for one child, isn't right for the next one.  You have to view them as individuals.  Cole has grown in amazing ways.  I am proud of him. His teachers really care about him, he is not just a number.  They want the best for him and push him. He participates in lengthy and difficult discussions.  He is encouraged to share his thoughts and ideas.  He writes a lot.  He reads challenging books.   It's not easy, he has to study.  I know that when he leaves for college in a few years that we have done the best we could to prepare him.  We provided a solid foundation.   The friends that he made in fourth grade are his real friends.  They are like minded and while it's not a perfect class, it's wonderful.  I read recently that "Who you spend time with is who you become."  These are kids that challenge and encourage Cole.  I think they will be lifelong friends and I am thankful.  The relationship Cole has with teachers who love him and with the other students affirm that we made the right choice for him.

I am not one hundred percent sure what we will do with Caleb in the fall.  As of now, he is enrolled at CCS and I think that is what will likely happen.  His class is not as cohesive at Cole's but the value of a classical education is still worthy to me.  This year Caleb is going to the manager of the baseball team and next year he will participate in Science Olympiad.  There are a few male teachers at CCS that really get Caleb and "speak" his language.  Those are a few of the reasons that we will likely leave Caleb there.  Also our local community does not have a CC program for 9th graders.  I am unsure that I would want to homeschool him without the support of a local community.

Claire will be entering Challenge A this August.  This is the "seventh grade" program in Classcial Conversations.  I am excited for her.  I think she will be pushed and  obviously challenged.  I am excited to see her grow!  I have high hopes that she will homeschool all the way through graduation because our CC community is growing.  In fact, this fall Classical Conversations will have two meeting days!  One group will meet on Tuesdays and another on Fridays.  She seems content being at home.  The struggle we experienced when she first came home is no longer there.  She is not asking to go back to school.  Will she ever go back to school?  Maybe, we take one year at a time. I don't know what the future holds but now, I am enjoying this season.

Cade will be in fourth grade next year.  He will be in Foundations and will begin Essentials.  Essentials is a grammar and writing program.  I don't know what that will look like for him.  I know much of it will go over his head but that's ok.  He will have two more years in the program which is part of the structure of CC.  The idea is to layer so what he misses the first time around, he will will get the second or third time through.

So that's our story.  It is long, complicated and messy.  We've made plenty more than five mistakes. I still question some of the decisions we've made.  Cole is going to college in a few years.  I think of all that money we have spent!  Then I remember mistake #4 and know that if God provided before, He can provide again.  It's a little thing called faith that is easy to say we have yet hard to exercise!  The bottom line is that education is an extremely personal decision.  You have to do what you think is best for your child.  Don't be afraid to do something different.  Pray about it.  Ask the Lord to make it obvious.  Seek the advice of families who are a few steps ahead of you in life.  Look at older kids you think are doing well and talk to their parents.  Our choices have not been easy.  They have been costly, literally and personally, but when I imagine each one of my kids ten years from now, I know that we are on the right path.   We will be shooting four arrows out into the world and I am excited to see how God uses all our mistakes for His glory!



No comments: