Sunday, April 5, 2015

The Girl Who Hated Math

"I am sorry, Mr. and Mrs. Coleman but clearly your daughter has a mental block in math."  That is what my eighth grade algebra teacher told my parents.  And then my parents told me.  Really?  Yes, really.  I don't know which is worse ~ that the teacher made the statement or that my parents told me what she said!  From that point forward, I determined that I would never ever be good at math.  There was no "consequence" at home for not doing well.  As long as I tried my very best, my parents were pleased.  If a "C" was my very best, then I received no complaint from them.  I really did try.  I was diligent and did not quit.  I just didn't understand it.  After Algebra I moved on to the next class, all the way through to Trigonometry.  I have no clue how I made it that far.  I do remember that two very smart twin sisters (who are still my friends today) helped me . . . . a lot.  I also remember a teacher, Mrs. Martin.  When I was doing poorly, my parents insisted I go in before school or during lunch to be tutored.  Mrs. Martin was a heavy smoker and her breath was rank.  If I close my eyes, I can still imagine being in my eleventh grade desk holding my breath as she leaned over my shoulder.  There was very little learning going on because I could not concentrate at all.  Her breath made me feel like throwing up and hate math even more.  I scraped by in math and graduated from high school with honors.  I don't know what my final grade in math was but I am thinking that my electives must have inflated my GPA!  It was that awful.  I hated math.

When I enrolled at East Carolina University, I searched for any major that did not require Algebra.  Yes, I did make a career decision based on whether or not I had to take college algebra.  I learned that a degree in Special Education did not require college algebra but some kind of consumer math.  So I enrolled in that track and made it through just fine.  I did consider other options but was too proud to be in remedial math lab so I stuck with the Special Education program.  If I remember correctly I took that one and only math class very early in my college experience.  I do remember taking a "How to teach Math" class later, probably my sophomore or junior year.  It was not a terribly complicated class but I would say it was one of my least favorites.  I only took it because I needed it to graduate.  Once again, I graduated from ECU with honors.  At that point I determined that I would never ever take another math class. . . . ever.

When Darren and I married, he knew all about my math phobia.  Now, I can figure out how to stretch a dollar but I have no clue how to keep the checkbook.  I update it everyday but I just enter the numbers.  I do not know how to reconcile my numbers with the numbers from the bank.  I may be more in charge of the "how much to spend category" but he has always been the one to balance the checkbook.  To this day, it is a two person job.  He could probably do it with one eye closed but maybe because he hopes I will learn by osmosis, I call out the numbers and he calculates.  I don't know what I did when he was deployed.  It is very possible that it was not balanced correctly for two years.  Maybe he updated it when he was home on leave.  It's that bad.  If he dies before I do, I hope one of my kids will keep my checkbook balanced because I still don't know how and I really don't want to learn.   I also don't know how you can graduate from high school and college with honor cords around your neck and not know how to balance a checkbook . . . . but that would be another blog!

As we began to have children, I determined that I would not pass my math phobia to them.  In other words, I would never say "Your teacher says you have a mental block against math."  Cole does well in math.  It is certainly not his favorite subject and at times he has stayed after school for extra help.  He has never made lower than a "B" so I consider him to be math literate.  For Caleb, numbers are kind of his deal.  He does most of the math in his head and I hardly ever remember him asking for help with math.  In fact, when he was in kindergarten he actually erased the board during a math lesson because he felt his teacher was taking too long to explain the process.  He is a total math guy. It drives me crazy sometimes.  When I am trying to calculate something aloud, he has the answer almost before I can finish the equation.  Most of the time, I don't even try to figure it out.  I just ask him and call it "homework."   Then along came Claire.  I wanted her experience to be different than mine and for awhile she was fine.  By the third grade though, she was fading fast.  It wasn't that the math was too difficult but the teacher was moving at such a rapid pace that she couldn't keep up.  By the time she grasped the concept, the teacher was on to the next topic.  That is the when the tears started.  She started saying "I am dumb in math or I'll never be good at it."  By the spring of her third grade year, she had decided she wanted to be homeschooled because math was that awful.  At the spring conference, her teacher admitted that she knew Claire was getting left behind but she was helpless to slow down because of the rest of the class.  There were so many things that were pulling at me to homeschool and Claire's math experience is part of the reason we began that journey.

One concern regarding homeschooling was that I am a "no math" Mom trying to teach my "no math" daughter.  I decided to let her work on a math program that was all on the computer.  She has a teacher that explains the lesson and even grades the work.  The first year, the math was really too easy for her.  I did that on purpose because I was trying to build her confidence.  By fifth grade, I began to accelerate the pace and she completed two math programs in one year. Even though she was doing better, she still would not consider herself to be very good at math.  When we met with our CC group and played mental math games, she would rarely volunteer.  She might have known the answer but would not raise her hand.  This school year, I moved her on yet again so that by next year she will be ready for pre-algebra just as if she were in school.  I don't know why that is important to me or maybe o do.  Clearly, I have still have issues by comparing our work to the school but if she ever goes back to school I want her to be on track.

This fall I noticed a change.  Claire was volunteering more often during math games at CC.  She was eager to participate.  Part of me would blush and hold my breath when she raised her hand.  I was scared she was going to be wrong but an amazing thing began to happen.  She was usually correct!  I would dare say she even became bold in giving her answer. She wanted to be called on so she could share the solution.

I wonder what helped with her confidence.  It may have been slowing down the pace.  It may be the daily math drills . . . . well, they are supposed to be daily but 3/5 days counts as daily right?  I am not sure what prompted this change.  She is still using the computer program and completes one lesson a day.  Lately, we've hit a few snags and she's had to go back and rework.  There have even been tears over the past few weeks.  She will say, "But I was only off by one decimal place!"  Math is funny like that.  It requires an exact answer.  It could be all of these things combined that have helped give her a little boost in math.  If you asked her, she would likely still say that math is not her favorite.  

Even though we have quite a bit left of our math journey, I can see progress.  I have realized that nailing down the basics is so important before moving on.  It is a delicate balance as her Mom and as her teacher.  I want to push her and make her do things even when they are hard.  As I type this, I realize how hypocritical that sounds.  Me, who doesn't want to learn the hard thing of balancing a checkbook yet making her daughter rework the math problems until they are correct.  Ugh!  That is the thing about homeschooling.  It is like walking around with a mirror attached at all times!  The very things I am working on refining in my kids are being refined in me.

So maybe neither of us will ever say that math is our favorite.  There are probably many things that are contributing to Claire's improvement in math.  I am going to resist the "I wonder how she would do at school" thought and just enjoy where we are today.  Teddy Roosevelt said, "Comparison is the thief of joy!"  I am also going to keep cheering her on and believing that while she may not "love" math that she can be a competent math student.  I want her to grow up differently.  I want her to believe that she is a mathematician.  For goodness sake, I don't want her to go to college and choose a major based on whether or not she has to take college algebra!  

I'm sure there will be more tears ~ from both of us!   There will be more tutoring sessions with Darren, who has a wonderful patient way of teaching Claire. For now though,  I want to remember how she looked two weeks ago after she was wonderfully successful playing the math game, Board Slam -- like a confident and sure mathematician!







No comments: